Skip to main content
Comparison8 min read·Updated November 9, 2026
🤖

Relay.app Alternatives 2026: 6 Tools With Human Approval

B

A. Frans

Published November 9, 2026

Relay.appWorkflow AutomationHuman in the LoopAI AgentsZapier

If you ran approvals through Relay.app, those workflows are gone. Relay's homepage now says the service closed in September 2026 and that every account, workflow and run history was permanently deleted. Free accounts lost access on August 15 and paid accounts on September 14, TechCrunch reported, and founder Jacob Bank went back to Google as VP of Product for Chrome.

Most "Relay alternatives" lists compare app counts. People picked Relay because a workflow could stop, show a person what the AI drafted, and carry on after that person said yes. So this comparison starts with the approval step and treats everything else as secondary.

We read each vendor's documentation and every pricing page that would load on November 9, 2026. We did not run production workloads on these tools. Where a vendor's own pages disagree or wouldn't load, we say so.

ToolApproval featureWhere the reviewer respondsEntry priceBest fit
ZapierHuman in the Loop: Request Approval, Collect DataZapier, and the reviewer needs an accountFree: 100 tasks. Pro: from $19.99/mo billed annuallyNon-technical teams that want an audit trail
n8nHuman review on AI Agent tool callsSlack, Teams, Gmail, Telegram, Discord and moreCloud from €20/mo billed annually, or self-hostTechnical teams running AI agents
ActivepiecesApproval step with a resume URL and timeoutEmail, chat or formFree: 1,000 credits. Plus: $20/moLowest published cost
GumloopApproval modes per connectorWeb chat, Slack, email, iMessage, Tasks pagePro from $37/mo, per Gumloop's blogAgent-first teams
LindyAsk for Confirmation on actions with side effectsLindy task view$50 of credits for 7 days, then from $29.99/user/moInbox and email assistants
MakeThird-party approval app in Make's directoryDepends on that appFree: 1,000 credits/moVisual builders with few approvals

What Relay did that you need to replace

Relay was a visual builder with AI agents, tables, reusable Sequences, MCP servers and about 200 app connections. Any of the tools below covers most of that list. The harder thing to replace is how its approval step worked. A reviewer could be assigned by role instead of by name, the request could carry workflow variables as context, and a run could be skipped, ended or reassigned from the review screen.

Before you shop, write down every point in your old workflows where a person had to act. For each one, note who approved, what they needed to see, and what should happen if nobody answered within a day. That list decides your pick faster than a feature grid will.

The six replacements, approval step first

Zapier: the closest like-for-like

Zapier has a built-in Human in the Loop app with two actions. Request Approval lets a reviewer approve, decline or edit the content, and you decide whether a decline stops the Zap or sends it down another path. Collect Data is for cases where the reviewer has to fill in fields. Admins get approvals and rejections in the account's audit log.

Two catches. Reviewers need a Zapier account, which is awkward if you used to send approvals to a contractor. Zapier's own pages also disagree on plan access: the help center lists the app on Free and up, while a Zapier blog guide says Pro and above and notes that Pro users can only send requests to themselves. Test this on your plan before you rebuild anything, because team approval is the whole point.

Pricing starts at 100 tasks a month on Free. Pro is $19.99 a month billed annually ($29.99 monthly) for 750 tasks, and Team is $69 billed annually for 2,000 tasks and up to 25 users. Zapier's guide says each successful Human in the Loop action counts as one task.

n8n: the strongest control over AI tool calls

n8n puts a Human review step between an AI Agent and the tools it can call. The workflow pauses, the reviewer sees the tool name and the parameters the model chose, and a denial cancels the action and tells the AI it was rejected, so the agent can respond sensibly. Requests can go to n8n Chat, Slack, Discord, Telegram, Microsoft Teams, Gmail, WhatsApp Business Cloud, Google Chat or Outlook.

The design is narrower than Relay's. It's documented as a gate on agent tool calls, so a plain non-agent workflow needs a different pattern. You also take on more building work, and hosting if you self-host. Cloud Starter is €20 a month billed annually for 2,500 executions, and Pro is €50 for 10,000.

Our Zapier, Make and n8n comparison goes deeper on the general trade-offs. If you drive n8n from a coding agent, see our n8n skills roundup.

Activepieces: the cheapest way to keep a person in the loop

Activepieces charges one credit per run regardless of step count, and AI steps add 2 credits for a fast model, 10 for a smart one or 20 for a frontier one. Free includes 1,000 credits and up to 5 users. Plus is $20 a month for 10,000 credits, and Team is $200 for 50,000 credits and 25 users. The community edition is MIT-licensed outside its enterprise folders and free to self-host (source).

Its README lists approval and delay as a core feature. According to the company's blog, a run stops at the approval step and generates a resume URL, the response becomes data that later steps can branch on, and a timeout can route to a fallback. We couldn't reach a technical reference page for this step, so build one small test flow before you commit.

Gumloop: approvals by connector

On Gumloop, you set a mode on each connector: Always allow, Ask each time, Ask for writes/deletes, Never allow, or Custom per tool. App Rules can add conditions based on tool arguments, such as asking only when an email goes outside the company.

"Ask for writes/deletes" is the setting most Relay refugees want, and you have to choose it, because the documented default is Always allow. Approvals can be answered in the web chat, the notification bell, the Tasks page, Slack, or by replying to an iMessage or email.

Gumloop's live pricing page wouldn't load for us. Its recent blog posts quote Pro from $37 a month, and they disagree with each other on free-tier credits, so confirm the numbers yourself.

Lindy: good for email, unpredictable on cost

Lindy shows an Ask for Confirmation field on actions that write to other apps. Turned on, the action waits as a draft in the task view until you approve it. For an inbox assistant, that's the behavior you want.

Billing is the weak spot. Lindy's pricing page starts Team at $29.99 per active user for 3,000 credits, and says an everyday ask uses 2 to 250 credits. That range means 3,000 credits could cover 12 asks or 1,500. Monthly credits don't roll over, top-ups cost $10 per 1,000, and credit-using actions pause when you run out. New accounts get $50 of credits that last 7 days, so use that week to measure your real per-task burn.

Make: strong builder, weak on this one job

Make is a capable visual builder, and Zapier's own comparison credits it with about 3,500 apps. On approvals, the option we found is a third-party listing in Make's app directory, Human Approval, which needs its own account and API key. We didn't find a first-party approval module, so check Make's current app list if this is a dealbreaker. The Free plan has 1,000 credits a month, and the pricing page we retrieved didn't show paid-plan figures.

Run the numbers before you migrate

Take a workflow that fires 500 times a month, with five billable actions (one of them the approval) and one AI step.

Zapier comes to about 2,500 tasks, which is past both entry tiers (750 on Pro and 2,000 on Team), so you'd be pricing a larger tier.

Activepieces with a smart model needs 500 runs at 1 credit plus 500 AI steps at 10 credits, or 5,500 credits. That fits inside the $20 Plus plan.

n8n's €20 Starter plan covers it with room to spare, since 500 executions is a fifth of its 2,500. Check separately how you'll pay for the AI model.

Lindy's published range is too wide to calculate this in advance, so measure it during the trial.

Rebuilding without your old files

If you exported before the deadline, treat the export as a specification. None of the six vendor pages we read mentions importing Relay files, so plan on rebuilding by hand. Work in this order:

1. Rebuild the workflow where a mistake costs the most, and leave the rest for later. 2. Send the approval to the person who'll approve it in production, on the real channel. 3. Test a decline and a no-response timeout. Most broken approval flows fail on those two paths. 4. Keep the first week of runs on manual approval, even for low-risk steps, because you have no old system to compare against.

For a wider view of the category, see our list of tools for small business owners and the Gumloop, n8n and Zapier breakdown.

Our pick

Most small teams leaving Relay should try Zapier first, provided the plan test above passes. It has the most direct approval action, a decline path and an audit log. Pick Activepieces if volume makes per-task pricing painful or you want to self-host. Pick n8n if your approvals are mostly about what an AI agent is allowed to do. We'd skip Make for approval-heavy work unless you're already on it.

Frequently Asked Questions

Is Relay.app still available?

No. Relay's homepage says the service shut down in September 2026 and that accounts, workflows and run history were permanently deleted. New signups are closed.

Can I recover my Relay workflows now?

Relay's homepage offers no export route and says the data was deleted. If you exported before the deadlines, use that file as a reference and rebuild by hand.

Which Relay alternative has the best human approval step?

Zapier has the most direct built-in action, with approve, decline and edit options plus an audit log. n8n is stronger when the thing being approved is an AI agent's tool call.

What is the cheapest Relay alternative with approvals?

Activepieces has the lowest published cost for most multi-step flows: one credit per run on a $20 plan with 10,000 credits, or free if you self-host the community edition.

Do reviewers need an account?

On Zapier, yes. On n8n, the request goes through a channel such as Slack or Gmail that you configure. Check each tool with a real reviewer before you migrate.

Share this article

📬

Get More AI Tool Guides

New comparisons and guides every week. Join thousands of professionals staying ahead of the AI curve.